Local

5 things to know about the Hutcherson murder trial

5 things to know about the Hutcherson murder trial

Timothy "True" Hutcherson is currently on trial for second degree murder at the Montgomery County Courthouse. Photo: Clarksville Now


CLARKSVILLE, Tenn. (CLARKSVILLENOW) — The trial for Timothy “True” Hutcherson, who is accused of second-degree murder, got underway Monday at the Montgomery County Courthouse.

Hutcherson is being tried for the 2017 shooting death of 21-year-old Devonte Wilkerson, and two counts of attempted murder for opening fire on an apartment on Beech Street.

The apartment was host to a birthday party, and a teenage girl in attendance suffered gunshot wounds in her leg. According to the indictment documents, the host of the party feared for her life, which resulted in another charge.

While Monday’s hearing was mostly focused on selecting the jury, new details about the initial incident came to light.

Here are five things you should know about this case, which is set to unfold over the next few days.

1. Hutcherson is being tried on eight counts

For the shooting on Beech Street, Hutcherson is charged with one count of second-degree murder, followed by two counts of attempted second-degree murder, two counts of possessing a firearm with intent while committing a felony, and two counts of aggravated assault.

Hutcherson is also being tried on reckless endangerment for discharging a firearm into an occupied dwelling, and he has pleaded not guilty to all counts.

2. State alleges Hutcherson was part of a gang

Lee Willoughby, the prosecutor on behalf of the state, alleged that Hutcherson was part of a gang. The apartment party where the shooting took place was attended by members of Hutcherson’s rival gang, Willoughby said.

As Hutcherson showed up to the party, he got out of the car with a gun in-hand, according to Willoughby. He was allegedly greeted by the party host, and then walked to the door, where he began firing into the apartment.

3. Seven rounds were fired

There were seven rounds that were fired, and the fatal wound that killed Wilkerson stemmed from a bullet in his right buttocks, the investigation found. Several of those shots ricocheted into the leg of a teenage girl who was also at the party. The prosecution believes the shell casings recovered at the scene support this story.

4. The defense is not refuting the shooting 

The argument put forth by the defense relied heavily on the reasoning behind the shooting.

Since Hutcherson was allegedly shooting through a metal door into the apartment where, according to the state, 10 to 20 people were gathered, the defense is trying to claim that Hutcherson therefore had no intent to kill.

“He might be guilty of reckless homicide,” Hutcherson’s attorney Jacob Fendley said. The prosecution then asked why, then, Hutcherson fired seven bullets, if that was in fact the case.

5. Hutcherson’s justification 

During Hutcherson’s interrogation, he told detectives two different stories. First, he told detectives that someone began firing after he arrived from a different location, and he believed that person was associated with the rival gang.

Then Hutcherson told a different story, telling detectives he thought he saw a member of the rival gang in the doorway of the apartment with a gun, and that’s why he began firing.

However, the prosecution rebutted this story Hutcherson, calling it the “Hoover Grassy Knoll Story,” with the “Hoover” being the name of the rival gang.

Latest Headlines

City council special session on June 29th. Council Chambers

yesterday in News

City Council to vote on withdrawing from local options sales tax agreement with county

This month the City Council is considering withdrawing from a local option sales tax agreement with Montgomery County.

First day of early voting in Clarksville on Wednesday, Oct. 14, 2026. (Wesley Irvin)

Thursday in Elections, News

Over 32,000 early votes in Montgomery County, on track to nearly 50% turnout

As of Thursday, the final day for early voting, 32,636 ballots had been cast in Clarksville and Montgomery County, similar to the 2018 midterm election.

Maj. Gen. Brett Sylvia at Fort Campbell's Memorial Day Ceremony on May 22, 2025. (Jeff Danault)

Thursday in Military, News

UPDATE: Pentagon fires former 101st Airborne commander Sylvia, citing information leaks

Sources say Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has fired Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia, former commanding general of Fort Campbell and the 101st Airborne Division.

Thursday in News

Halloween forecast: Rain slides later, clearing way for trick-or-treating in Clarksville

The Halloween forecast has improved, with rain not expected until overnight Saturday into Sunday morning in Clarksville.

Plans for the Central Park entry to Ascension Saint Thomas Clarksville Hospital, as of October 2026. (AST, contributed)

Thursday in News

Ascension Saint Thomas names Clarksville hospital president, community board members

Ascension Saint Thomas has named Jake Golich the first president and CEO of the Ascension Saint Thomas Clarksville Hospital and established an inaugural Community Advisory Board.

Latest Headlines

20 hours ago in Sports, Trending

Brewers fans flood Milwaukee streets for a long-awaited World Series victory celebration

It was only fitting that the Milwaukee Brewers celebrated their first World Series title with a beer-soaked celebration worthy of their name. "We've had way too many parade beers," team captain and designated hitter Christian Yelich said Friday at a rally that capped a daylong party with fans.

20 hours ago in Entertainment

Prosecutors drop felony charge against rapper Rick Ross in domestic violence case

Prosecutors have dropped a felony charge against rapper Rick Ross a month after he was arrested in Miami Beach when a woman he was living with told police he hit her, court records said.

1 day ago in Entertainment

Hugh Jackman, William Shatner and George Takei among those paying tribute to Patrick Stewart

The death of Patrick Stewart at 86 led to a slew of tributes, including from acting colleagues and even Marvel Studios. Known for his roles as Capt. Jean-Luc Picard in "Star Trek" and Professor Charles Xavier in the "X-Men" films, Stewart died in Los Angeles on Wednesday after what his spokesperson described as a "brief and poignant journey" with Alzheimer's disease and Lewy Body Dementia.

1 day ago in National, Trending

Pope Leo XIV has become the first pope in history to vote in a US general election

Pope Leo XIV has become the first pope to vote in a U.S. general election. The Vatican confirmed Friday that the Chicago-born pontiff had submitted a mail-in ballot in Chicago ahead of November's midterm elections, citing his long-standing belief in civic participation.

2 days ago in Lifestyle, Trending

Make no bones about it, the giant skeleton has become an American Halloween fixture

It reared its bony head in 2020, during that first, chaotic pandemic year that was rife with grief and fear but also toilet paper hoarding and questionable lockdown-inspired purchases. Behold Skelly, the 12-foot, 90-pound skeleton with glowing LCD eyeballs, on sale for $299 from Home Depot, just in time for Halloween — at least, if you can get your hands on one.